Mind & Body
Separate and yet interdependent, the two halves of our
existence.
Why do we talk about mind and body rather than brain and body?
Perhaps because we see the brain as a physical entity, controlling
the nervous system and bodily functions, while the mind holds
memory, emotion and personality. In the past, society might have
considered the essence of what makes an individual the 'soul', and
the seat of the soul hasn't always been considered to be the brain.
The Babylonians thought that human emotion and spirit resided in
the liver; the Egyptians, that the soul (or 'ka') was located in
the heart. The Mesopotamians hedged their bets with the theory that
intellect lay in the heart, emotions in the liver and cunning in
the stomach.
Are the mind and the body separate? Western medicine seems to
have come full circle, beginning and ending with an approach that
recognises the interdependency of mind and body, bracketing several
hundred years when the two were approached as distinct entities.
'It's all in his head' seems to have faded from popular parlance
over recent decades as we come to understand that the vast majority
of afflictions have both mental and physical aspects.
Unless the symptoms are very pronounced, it can be hard to 'see'
mental illness. For the individual trying to disguise their
condition this can be an advantage: mental illness continues to
have a stigma attached to it. Society seems to be more comfortable
with a broken leg than a broken spirit - more acceptable, more
predictable, easier to cure. Now we understand a little more about
the brain and body, we seem determined to 'fix' anything that leads
an individual to stray from the norm. Is the problem with the
person who is 'different', or with a society which finds it
difficult to accept and cater for this difference? Why do we find
it easier to accept someone who has mental health issues as a
result of an accident or stroke, than we do someone who has
developed schizophrenia or bipolar disorder?
For the majority of historically recorded medicine, patients
have been treated holistically - in much the same way that
alternative medicine and medical care in other cultures has always
done. Within the framework of the four humours it was taken for
granted that the balance of elements in each individual would
affect their personality, as well as which conditions they might be
most susceptible to. Most obvious would be those of a melancholic
disposition - the glass half-empty people, the 'Eeyores' among us
who need to guard against depression.
From the Renaissance onwards, as knowledge increased, ways of
seeing the body diversified. For some the body was a machine, with
pumps and valves, levers and hinges; for others the body was a
collection of chemical processes and reactions, such as the
breaking down of food and creation of heat. Seen from a mechanical
perspective, the body becomes something very different from the
mind.
Considering the physical construction of the brain is
considerably harder. Researchers have approached the brain from
many directions: physical, chemical, electrical, behavioural. The
incredible ability of the brain to adapt, learn, interpret and
anticipate underlines the complexity of this most vital organ and
how much more there is discover.