Stereotyping and Fatism
Overweight and obese people are usually viewed
negatively. As well as being held up to ridicule, obese people are
also subject to discrimination and anti-fat bias.
If Marilyn Monroe were an aspiring young actress today, she
would be deemed too chubby for Hollywood. Her legendary figure fit
the 1950s ideal of female beauty but since then curves are out -
thin is in.
The size of aisles and seats in buses, airplanes, cinemas and
waiting rooms are all suited to people with a slim build, while
fashionable clothing seems to be designed only with the slim in
mind. Each day large people get the message that they are not
desirable or 'normal'.
We assume that thin people are successful, sexy and happy while
large people are ugly, unhealthy and undesirable. The 'fat person'
stereotype is that they are lazy and slothful. People's size can
affect their chances of getting a job, being accepted in higher
education, and the salary they receive.
Our stereotypes have a long history. Take Shakespeare. Julius
Caesar refers to Cassius's "lean and hungry look", evidence of his
ambition and plotting; in 'Henry the Fourth part 1', Falstaff is
the continual butt of Prince Hal's jokes: having double-crossed him
in a highway robbery prank, the Prince laughs as Falstaff flees in
panic:
...Falstaff sweats to death,
And lards the lean earth as he walks along:
Were't not for laughing, I should pity him.
Throughout most of history, female fat has been a signal of
fertility and sexuality. The most famous early image of a woman is
a small figurine known as the Venus of Willendorf, which is thought
to date between 24 000 and 22 000 BCE. And she is very large indeed
- obese by our standards.
So, if they are lucky, large females may be 'cuddly' or an
'Earth Mother'. More often, though, 'they have let themselves
go'.
Further reading
Rebecca Puhl and Kelly D Brownell, 'Bias, Discrimination, and
Obesity', Obesity Research 9:788-805 (2001)
A review of information on discriminatory attitudes and behaviours
against obese individuals. Concludes that "clear and consistent
stigmatization, and in some cases discrimination, can be documented
in three important areas of living: employment, education, and
health care".
Wang SS, Brownell KD, Wadden TA, 'The influence of the stigma of
obesity on overweight individuals', J Obes Relat Metab Disord
28(10):1333-7 (2004)
Even overweight patients at a weight reduction clinic held anti-fat
opinions: "Unlike other minority group members, overweight
individuals do not appear to hold more favorable attitudes toward
ingroup members."
Janet D Latner and Albert J Stunkard, 'Getting Worse: The
Stigmatization of Obese Children', Obesity Research 11:452-456
(2003)
Children hold negative views of obese people, and comparison with a
study carried out in 1961 indicates that views are becoming more
negative: "Stigmatization of obesity by children appears to have
increased over the last 40 years."
Marlene B Schwartz, Heather O'Neal Chambliss, Kelly D Brownell,
Steven N Blair and Charles Billington, 'Weight Bias among Health
Professionals Specializing in Obesity', Obesity Research
11:1033-1039 (2003)
Health care professionals don't think much of obese people either:
"Even professionals whose careers emphasize research or the
clinical management of obesity show very strong weight bias,
indicating pervasive and powerful stigma."