Time & Place
Medicine in history and culture.
"... the 'great men of medicine' performing the Wonderful Onward
March of Medical Progress."
This is how Dr Lesley Hall of the Wellcome Library has described
past perceptions of the history and development of medicine, when
it was held that Western medicine progressed in a linear and
straightforward fashion from the superstitions and quackery of
'then' to the advanced medicine of 'now'. This was the medical
equivalent of the Whig view of history, which saw the past in terms
of an inevitable progression towards modern democracy and
enlightenment. Its two main strands were the study of pioneers -
Hall's 'great men of medicine' (and they generally were men) such
as William Harvey, Edward Jenner and Joseph Lister - and histories
of institutions including hospitals.
In the last few decades, the history of medicine has been
transformed, creating much less linear and organised, but
nonetheless more interesting and diverse, perspectives. The history
of medicine now embraces non-Western traditions, both in their own
right and also in terms of how they fed in to Western medical
traditions. Alternative and informal health practices are studied,
as well as the interface between medicine, magic and religion. The
experiences of patients have become a legitimate subject for
inclusion, as have the social factors that influence the experience
of illness, getting sick, paths to treatment and the nature of that
treatment. There has also been more interest in the female
experience of healthcare - traditionally men have dominated both
medicine and the writing of history. Interest in the pioneers of
medicine continues, but they are now more likely to be placed
within the context of times, and of the work of others around
them.
The history of medicine, once written largely by doctors, is now
a flourishing historic academic discipline, with Britain considered
to be a leader in the field. Over 40 institutions in the UK offer
medical history courses at undergraduate or masters level, many
funded by the Wellcome Trust. The success of exhibitions relating
to medical history, not least those at the Wellcome Collection, is
testimony to the public's continuing interest in the subject.
The history of medicine is now also linked into wider historical
and cultural perspectives, ranging from the political processes
involved in the development of welfare states to gender attitudes
within society and popular beliefs about health and the body.
Medical history has forged links with other disciplines including
theology, literary studies, economics, anthropology, sociology and
health economics.
Increasing specialisation within the history of medicine has
encouraged historians to focus on medicine in a particular time
period, or in a specific place, for example London. There is also
increasing interest in medicine in non-western cultures,
particularly Islamic medicine, and research into specific themes
that cut across time, for example the study of perceptions of pain
or mental health in different historical periods, or the
development of medicine in warfare.
As historians assumed the responsibility for the study of
medical history from doctors, history and medicine seemed to be
placing themselves in separate camps, with little in common. The
relationship has in fact shifted, but significant interaction
continues. Many medical students choose to study the history of
medicine as part of their medical studies, and history of medicine
departments within universities forge relationships with medical
and health care practitioners and organisations.
Studying recent medical history can be challenging for
historians, particularly as medicine and medical technology become
ever more complex and the speed of development increases. Whole new
themes are emerging for historians to grapple with, including
genetics and nanotechnology, as well as less tangible ideas such as
the 'worried well'.
Sickness and medicine touch everyone. The best medical history
does not only tell the stories of the doctors and scientists who
advanced medical knowledge, or the institutions through which
people received their healthcare. It also speaks about the health
or sickness of individuals, which in turn encompasses how people
live, what they eat, how they organise their lives and how they
understand the world. All this serves to reinforce Henry Wellcome's
belief that the history of medicine can illuminate the whole of
human life.