The global context of organ donation
Transplantation is now a routine surgical procedure in many
countries. Broadly speaking, the number of procedures carried out
is linked to a country's economic status - the richer a country,
the more transplants take place.
Many countries follow the UK example and operate an 'opt-in'
form of consent. Since demand always exceeds supply, this leads to
waiting lists and the death of patients while they wait for a donor
organ.
To get round this problem, some countries have swapped opt-in
for 'presumed consent' (opt-out) approaches -
doctors will remove suitable organs after death unless someone has
specifically expressed a wish not to be an organ donor.
This may mean that more organs are available, and ensures that
organs are used from people in favour of organ donation but not on
the organ donor register. On the other hand, it raises ethical
questions about the rights we have over our bodies after death, and
how we respect the wishes of those who do not want to donate.
Countries operating presumed consent include Spain, Austria,
Sweden, France, Chile and Brazil.
Iran has gone further still, and allows the sale of organs.
Iranian doctors have claimed that, thanks to live organ donation,
there are no longer any waiting lists for liver and kidney
transplants (though this has been disputed). Critics argue that
this policy puts pressure on poor people to donate organs,
potentially harming their health. In some Pakistani villages, 40-50
per cent of adult men have only one kidney, having sold the other
for use in rich countries.
China has increased its use of donor organs by taking them from
executed prisoners - of around 10 000 transplants a year, perhaps
90 per cent involve organs taken from executed prisoners, without
consent. Organisations such as Amnesty International have
criticised this practice.
In some countries, cultural taboos restrict the use of
transplantation. In China, for example, family members will rarely
agree to the removal of organs after death. Israel also has a
severe shortage of organs, as some religious leaders do not support
organ donation.
Japan has also been slow to introduce transplantation. This
originates in the scandal surrounding the world's second heart
transplant operation, carried out by a Japanese doctor in 1969. He
was responsible for declaring the donor brain dead and also carried
out the operation (a conflict of interest now outlawed). When the
patient died, the doctor was charged with murder. Japanese culture
has also seen the body's 'spirit' as being part of the body as well
as the brain, and the concept of brain death is not widely
accepted. Heart transplants in Japan did not start until 1999, and
even today many Japanese will not donate organs for fear of being
declared 'brain dead' while still alive.